How we actually decide a strategy game's score
People sometimes ask why we gave a popular game a 4.2 when everyone else hands out 5s. Fair question. Our score is about how a game holds up over real time, not the first hour buzz.
We weigh three things: how good the core loop is, how fairly it treats your time, and whether it keeps surprising you. A game can nail the first and flunk the third, and that caps the score.
We also note performance on older phones, because not everyone is playing on the latest hardware. A brilliant game that stutters is still a frustrating game.
None of this is a formula you can plug numbers into. In the end an editor plays it, thinks about it, and commits to a number. We'd rather be honestly subjective than pretend to be objective.
